| No Fear of Freedom |
|
| Anti-right rants from an obnoxious lumpen proletarian. Aiming to Arm the Choir. |
February 21, 2004 Immoral Minority Corrupts Majority - On PovertyRich Lowry, NRO, wrote:Unless Democrats offer serious solutions to poverty, however, the poor only serve as props for their moral vanity.True, true, all too true. And if the Repukelicans offer false and misleading solutions to poverty, what do the poor serve as? Total Poverty Awareness, an op-ed by David Shipler, a former NY Times correspondent and Pulitzer winner for non-fiction, who spent nine years working on The Working Poor: Invisible in America. Some educators and other specialists speak of a "culture of poverty" [And Heritage says the inferior culture of those damned inferior black folks is what's really holdin' down. And how dare you call that racist?] as if it were a collection of mores, values and rituals. But poverty is not a culture. It's more like an ecological system of relationships among individuals, families and the environment of schools, neighborhoods, jobs and government services. Professionals who aid the poor witness the toxic interactions every day. Doctors see patients affected by dangerous housing, erratic work schedules, transportation difficulties and poor child-rearing skills. Teachers see pupils undermined by violence at home and malnutrition.Extrapolate, pibbles. And at least read the op-ed if not the book. This is tip of the iceberg stuff. And the great moral arbiters of the right condemn the poor for not grabbing the chance they were never given. I discuss one of the major falsehoods the Heritage con-Foundation has used create an "everybody knows" mythology about the unwed birthrate in How The Immoral Minority Sells The Republican Agenda. It ain't hardly an isolated case. The technique is always the same. Come up with a lie that people want to hear, usually a lie that justifies greed and selfishness, a lie that focuses hostility on the victims rather than the perpetrators, like the "culture of victimization" lie intended to demonize victims by denying their existence. The modern conservative is engaged in one of man's oldest exercises in moral philosophy; that is, the search for a superior moral justification for selfishness.Then gather a careful selection of facts and statistics taken out of context and twisted to look as though they prove something they emphatically do not, throw in a few juicy anecdotes a la Raygun, and publicize, publicize, publicize. Voila, a new cultural myth is born. The f'right dingers' professional super propagandists should have "egregious" tattooed on their foreheads. Shipler says services for the poor are scattered, compartmentalized, difficult and time-consuming to access and therefore many of the poor, especially the working poor, don't get benefits. One remedy, tried by community action centers created by the War on Poverty, put a variety of specialists under one roof. Their effectiveness unsettled politicians. "Mayors didn't like them because they were doing something that was very good," recalls Frances Fox Piven, a professor of political science and sociology at City University of New York. "They were badgering municipal agencies to provide services." The money for the centers eventually dried up.Mayors didn't like them because providing benefits costs more money than pretending to provide benefits. "Those rat bastard mayors!" Not so hasty, now. Pretending to provide benefits has high electoral value. Providing benefits runs into the law of diminishing returns in a hurry. Imagine this next part as a political speech. We need more than patchwork projects[!] We need a sweeping national program to create what could be called gateways. At private and public institutions that are frequented every day — clinics, schools, food banks, housing projects, police precincts and the like — a person should be able to find easy referrals to child-rearing instruction, drug treatment and whatever other assistance people need[!]And all the pibbles scream, "Yeah! Yeah! What a wonderful man! Let's all vote for Mr. Compassion! !"[Mr. Compassion then adds, "Of course, all this will require a tax increase."]And all the good pibbles say, "FUCK YOU!!!" What works is an intensive, holistic approach like the one used by the Maya Angelou Charter School in Washington. The school brings its 100 students in for breakfast and keeps them until after dinner. They have small classes, homework sessions with 75 volunteers and counseling from three full-time social workers and a psychologist. Most students arrive in 10th grade reading at sixth- or seventh-grade levels; three years later 70 percent go to college. The cost isn't low — it runs over $25,000 annually per student — but it is a humane investment, one that is helped in part by donations. With more money, the school could become a platform for supporting whole families.See, we know what works. That ain't the problem. The problem is we don't know what works on the cheap. |
|